Old Erowal Bay is generally considered an average suburb compared to other suburbs in St Georges Basin-Sanctuary Point. Crime rates are below the Greater St Georges Basin-Sanctuary Point average, with Assault being the most commonly reported violent crime, and Theft the most commonly reported property crime. From 2023 to 2024, Violent crime rates have increased by 54.54%, and Property crime rates have increased by 87.51%.

As with any area, it is recommended to stay aware of your surroundings and take the usual safety precautions.